Something I want you to understand about where I am right nowI want to explain what's been going on with me today, because I don't think it's just about the argument we had over conditioner.
That argument brought up a much bigger feeling that I've been carrying for a long time: frustration, disappointment, and sometimes a sense of hopelessness when I feel like something has been discussed, understood, agreed upon, and then eventually goes right back to the way it was. I've spent a lot of time trying to explain things clearly, find ways to make them easier to understand, and work through disagreements with you. So when something happens that makes it feel as though all of that effort has disappeared, it can hit me pretty hard.
But I also recognize that the conditioner issue and the affair are not the same thing. I'm not saying that using too much conditioner is equivalent to betraying our marriage. It isn't. What happened today simply stirred up some of the frustration and resentment I still have about the affair and, especially, what happened afterward.
And that's where a lot of my anger is coming from.
The affair itself was devastating. But the way things unfolded after I found out added another layer of hurt. There was the lying, the minimizing, the continued contact, the defensiveness, the way you sometimes defended him, and the things you said to other people while I was being given a different picture of what was happening. There were times when I felt that you were more concerned with protecting yourself, or even protecting him, than with understanding what you had done to me.
I shouldn't have had to dig through messages and piece things together to understand what was happening. I shouldn't have had to keep pushing for honesty. And I certainly shouldn't have had to fight for empathy from the person who had hurt me.
One thing that was particularly painful was hearing you say, when I criticized him for pursuing a married woman, that it wasn't all him, that you were willing too. I understand what you meant. You were acknowledging your own responsibility, and you were right to do that. But in that moment, I wasn't asking you to remind me that you had willingly participated. I already knew that. I was hurting, and hearing you emphasize your willingness felt like another painful reminder rather than an acknowledgment of what I was going through.
I don't want you to misunderstand me. I believe you have made real progress. I believe you recognize that what you did was wrong. I believe you feel genuinely awful about the affair and about how you treated me afterward. I see the changes in your behavior, the affection, the closeness, and the effort you've made toward our marriage. I don't dismiss any of that.
But there's something I still struggle with.
When you apologize, it's often something along the lines of, "I know I hurt you. I'm sorry for hurting you." I believe you mean it. I'm not necessarily questioning your sincerity. But those words are general, and the things that happened to me weren't general. They were specific experiences, specific betrayals, and specific moments when I needed you and felt abandoned by you.
What I want is to know that you understand those individual experiences, not just that you understand the overall conclusion that you hurt me.
For example, you've brought up leaving me on the side of the road and said that you feel awful about it and can only imagine how that made me feel. That means something to me. But we've talked about that incident many times. You know how painful it was for me.
What I'm still looking for is more evidence that you think about the other things yourself, without me having to bring them up first. Do you ever independently think about the times you defended AP? The times you continued communicating with him after I found out? The things you said to friends? The dishonesty and minimizing? Do you think about what those experiences were like for me, and what they did to my ability to trust you?
There's a difference between responding when I remind you that something hurt me and independently recognizing that you did something hurtful.
I'm not asking you to memorize a list of offenses or give me a perfectly worded apology. I'm not asking you to repeat something just because you think it's what I want to hear. I want to know that you've actually thought about these things, that you've considered what they were like from my side, and that you can recognize the damage without needing me to explain it all over again.
I also understand that putting complicated feelings into words isn't always easy for you. I know you sometimes struggle to explain what you're thinking, and I don't want to mistake difficulty expressing something for an absence of feeling. But I don't want that difficulty to become a reason we never get to the deeper understanding, either.
I have spent a tremendous amount of time trying to help you understand what happened, why it hurt, and how your behavior affected me. I don't regret trying to communicate with you. But I don't want to be the only one doing the work of revisiting the past and recognizing what happened.
I want to see you take some initiative in that process.
And I need you to understand why I still have doubts sometimes. You lied to me. You withheld information. You denied things that eventually turned out to be true. I spent a long time not knowing whether what you were telling me was the whole truth. That doesn't automatically mean there's more you're hiding, and I don't want to treat suspicion as proof. But it does mean that trust isn't something I can simply switch back on because things are good between us now.
I'm trying to build that trust again. Your behavior today matters, and so does your behavior over the past year and a half. I see it. But the history matters, too. Both things can be true: you can be making genuine changes now, and I can still be carrying considerable hurt from what happened before.
I don't want to live in the past. I don't want every disagreement to become an argument about the affair. I want the marriage we're building now. I enjoy being close to you. I enjoy the affection and intimacy we've regained. I value the relationship we have today.
But I can't pretend the past didn't happen just because the present is better.
What I need most isn't another general apology or another promise that things will be different. I need to feel that you understand what you did, including the ways you made an already terrible situation worse after discovery. I need to see that understanding reflected not only in how you respond when I bring something up, but in what you recognize and acknowledge on your own.
I don't expect you to fix everything today. I don't expect perfect words. And I'm not telling you this because I want you to feel terrible or because I want to punish you.
I'm telling you because I want you to understand where I am. I want us to keep moving forward, but I need to feel that we're both doing the work of understanding what happened, not just trying to get past it.
I love you, and I believe in the progress we've made. I just need you to understand that there is still some hurt here that hasn't completely healed. And sometimes, when something else goes wrong, it brings that hurt right back to the surface.