Cookies are required for login or registration. Please read and agree to our cookie policy to continue.

Newest Member: MissTee00

Wayward Side :
When Is Omission TT?

stop

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 2:29 AM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

H has become hyper-focused on some new projects, and I'm very proud of him, his ideas, and his ambition. However, yesterday he mentioned needing to use ElevenLabs for one of them, and without thinking, I cheerfully told him I already had a subscription that I'd forgotten to cancel which he could use... And then he asked me why. I was mortified to have to explain that after I cut contact with the AP, my self-esteem was so pathetically tattered that I came up with compliments that sounded like something AP would say, and downloaded MP3s of an AI voice that sounded like him saying them. I walked around the house playing them every time I did something good or productive for a couple weeks when H wasn't home. It got me through until I could compliment myself, and accept those compliments. (He made his own account after hearing about it.)

Like I said, absolutely mortifying. I never told him because it was so embarrassing, and I thought it would only hurt his feelings or make him think I was still attached to the AP. But it came to light last night, and it's making me wonder: where is the line between TT and omissions? Am I still trying to predict what he can and can't handle, and withholding that level of information from him? Is there anything else lingering that I've forgotten about? Is there a justifiable reason to keep that kind of thing to oneself? Or am I just being manipulative?

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909636
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 2:43 AM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

I attempted to make one for H, but he has a pretty unique voice, and I couldn't come up with any kind of compliment that he would actually say to me to make it believable, at the time... Also, there's something about a compliment given in a chipper southern drawl that makes it feel so earnest and blush-inducing. Like it's amplified... I tried it with a southern woman's voice too, tbf.

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909639
default

Unconventional ( member #87720) posted at 3:40 AM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

That wasn’t cheating. Maybe not one of your proudest moments, but not a TT failing and not manipulative. Incidentally, what an innovative and ethical way of helping yourself cope! Although… I suppose I would’ve rather you cloned H’s voice and compliments he might’ve given you!

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 189   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909638
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 3:42 AM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

I did not mean to make this a stop signed post. So if any mods come across this message, could you please kindly remove the stop sign? Please and thanks.

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909642
default

1994 ( member #82615) posted at 5:04 PM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

Speaking as a BP (also a madhatter), I think this is a case study on how we're getting into new possibilities with infidelity. More people are creating digital AI partners and developing "real" relationships with them. Creepy...but growing at an alarming rate among young, lonely, socially isolated people. The negative birth rate in Japan is reportedly in part tied to younger people believing they don't need a human connection because they can create their own partners.
I do think what you did would be classified as cheating...technically. Women are well-understood to be much more verbally-oriented and your AP continued providing for your needs after the affair otherwise ended. You kept him as a digital twin to keep giving you what, I imagine, you had been getting from the affair. That you couldn't replicate that for your husband may be true, but I would still feel like you were holding on to your affair and feel emasculated that you had to create essentially an ego-stroking robot instead of spending that energy on an emotional connection with me.
How did he take it when you told him?

posts: 310   ·   registered: Dec. 25th, 2022   ·   location: USA
id 8909669
default

SI Staff ( Moderator #10) posted at 5:31 PM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

The Stop Sign has been removed smile

[This message edited by SI Staff at 12:36 AM, Wednesday, November 18th]

posts: 10036   ·   registered: May. 30th, 2002
id 8909674
default

Asterisk ( member #86331) posted at 2:08 PM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

GotTheMorbs,

I never told him because it was so embarrassing, and I thought it would only hurt his feelings or make him think I was still attached to the AP.


I cannot speak for your husband only from how I, as a betrayed husband, would take it. My "feelings" would be profoundly "hurt" and yes I would not only "think" you were still "attached" to your "AP" I would be confident of it. I don’s say this to be mean but think about it. When you were involved with your affair partners you were taking a risk and hiding stuff from your marriage partner. Right? How is what you did with the voice recordings any different. You took another risk and hid it from your husband. It is simple math for a husband to add up and deduce you are still tethered to your affair partner.


But it came to light last night, and it's making me wonder: where is the line between TT and omissions?


This question puzzles me. Honestly, omission is a furthering of the betrayal, right? Trickle Truth is just an extension of omission because only partial truths are being given, do we agree on that principle? In both cases are you not controlling the narrative and conducting yourself in a way that is controlling the information flow to your husband. Is that what you want in your relationship with your spouse?

Am I still trying to predict what he can and can't handle, and withholding that level of information from him? Is there anything else lingering that I've forgotten about? Is there a justifiable reason to keep that kind of thing to oneself? Or am I just being manipulative?


Again, I can only speak from my experience. My wife never gave me a full accounting of what went on between her and her affair partners. Despite that fact, we still reconciled and have developed a marriage that is wonderful. I am proud of her self-improvement (and mine) over the years, she has proven herself to be an amazing woman and life-partner. However, that lack of full accounting has assisted in leaving lingering thoughts in my head. Imaginations that probably are much worse than what actually occurred. In my mind, her "reason to keep that kind of thing to oneself (Herself)", left a vacuum that I could not pinpoint but could feel it in my bones. And, in my thoughts, you are continuing the "manipulation". I don’t think you are doing it out of malicious intent, but it is by a different intent, and that is what I would ask you to try to figure out - what is my intent here?

I would like to end by stating that reading struggles of waywards has been an invaluable asset in helping me to develop empathy for my wife. For that, I am forever grateful.

Asterisk

posts: 541   ·   registered: Jul. 7th, 2025   ·   location: AZ
id 8909712
default

LittleMonk ( member #86661) posted at 2:34 PM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

I created a thread about secrets a while back, and I think the distinction between privacy and secrecy is relevant here.

An omission can be a secret, but it can also simply be privacy. If it's a secret, I would consider it TT. If it's privacy, I would not.

The difference, to me, comes down to how you anticipate the information will be received by your spouse and why you are choosing not to disclose it.

Privacy is keeping something to yourself because it is personal. Secrecy is withholding something because of how you believe your spouse will react to knowing it. If withholding the information feels "protective," or if you are reluctant to disclose it because you believe it will upset your spouse, then I would argue you are keeping a secret rather than maintaining privacy.

In your case, you specifically said you withheld the information because you thought it would hurt his feelings or make him believe you were still attached to your AP. That seems to fall pretty clearly on the secrecy side of the distinction.

The problem is that you are still making decisions about what your husband should know based on how you think he will respond, rather than allowing him to decide for himself what the information means to him.

- LM BH Reconciled

Dday: 12/2024

"The hardest cage to sit in is the one where you hold the key, knowing exactly what freedom looks like on the outside."

posts: 115   ·   registered: Oct. 10th, 2025   ·   location: North Carolina
id 8909716
default

sisoon ( Moderator #31240) posted at 4:51 PM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

You seem to be saying that you remembered your subscription but kept it from your H. That's TT to me, probably not a deal killer, but I'd be pretty angry if my W TTed, maybe furious and maybe scared, too.

You can't change what you did. You can, however, dig deep and tell your H about anything else you've knowingly hidden, and you can commit to telling him about any memories of the A that surface.

Really, the best you can do is pick yourself up, accept responsibility, and restart being honest. You can't control your H.

I hope whatever your H chooses to do works out well for you all. At this point that seems tantamount to hoping you continue in R, but really, giving up trying to control the outcome is the best strategy.

fBH (me) - on d-day: 66, Married 43, together 45, same sex ap
d-day - 12/22/2010 Recover'd and R'ed
You don't have to like your boundaries. You just have to set and enforce them.

posts: 32358   ·   registered: Feb. 18th, 2011   ·   location: Illinois
id 8909720
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 10:43 PM on Wednesday, November 18th, 2026

When I told H he listened silently with this really strange, strained expression, with like a slight, weird smile that only affected his mouth and no other parts of his face, and his eyes looked wide and damp, though he didn't cry. I've never seen anything like it and it made me really uncomfortable. He was quiet, so I found myself babbling on repetitively, pausing every so often in hopes of recieving any kind of feedback, but it never came. The only thing he said was he'd prefer to get his own account, and then he left the room. (Idk if this is related or not, but he took my old phone with him to work today, saying it was because his was getting its battery replaced. But that the old phone is basically non-functional, so I wonder if this triggered him to go get a data extraction or something... I feel anxious wondering if there's anything else I've forgotten about...)

I think at the time when I was using the ElevenLabs mp3s, I was genuinely emotionally detached from the AP, and came to see him as a liar, an alcoholic, and a bad person for enabling my A. But I was still in withdrawal from the external validation he had given me, and I hadn't figured out how to validate and feel good about myself yet, so I used the mp3s to cope. I felt embrrassed about it because that's such a pathetic thing to do. Like a dog responding to a clicker...

I think I believed that even if the mp3s were meant to sound like the AP, it wasn't cheating as long as it wasn't a real person, and I didn't think H would believe me about being over the AP if he knew I was doing it at the time. I'm pretty sure he's presently taking it as a sign that I wasn't over him back then. I did take steps to keep the mp3 use under wraps, only playing them when I was alone... but to me it leans more towards "privacy" (or at least a desire for privacy) than a secret, sort of like how you might engage in a gross or embarrassing habit like popping a zit or waxing your buttcrack in private rather than in view of your spouse because they just don't need to see you like that...

Similarly, I believed H didn't need to know about the mp3s. But idk, I guess since it's related to the infidelity, it wasn't information that I should have omitted? I'm having conflicting thoughts and feelings on the matter. It feels like a very gray area.

I kept the ElevenLabs susbcription because I thought I would get books from Google books that weren't on audible and have them read to me by the program, just to clarify.

I appreciate all of you guys sharing your opinions on this. Thank you.

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909745
default

WoodThrush2 ( member #85057) posted at 2:02 AM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

I guess I don't understand how you would think this action is not integrally linked to the affair and was not continuation of active betrayal?

And if your husband wanted to know all aspect of your betrayal and you did not tell him....that was continued deception and lies.

I may have missed but did you say of your were doing this AFTER D-Day?

Let me pose this illustration on how one may look at this. Suppose your husband had affairs with a woman and you found out. He stopped affairs but continued to self pleasure to her naked photos stored on his phone....or AI generated photos of her?

Would you not consider that continuation of the affair? His affections and validation were still being impacted by an image of the AP.....instead of you.

Would you not want the opportunity to tell him that was unacceptable to you?

[This message edited by WoodThrush2 at 2:02 AM, Thursday, November 19th]

posts: 525   ·   registered: Jul. 29th, 2024   ·   location: New York
id 8909753
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 3:49 AM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

I guess I don't understand how you would think this action is not integrally linked to the affair and was not continuation of active betrayal?

And if your husband wanted to know all aspect of your betrayal and you did not tell him....that was continued deception and lies.

As I sad, I reasoned that because I was maintaining NC with the AP and that I was over him, but still seeking validation, that the AI-generated mp3s were an acceptable, temporary coping mechanism, rather than continued infidelity. I still view it as pathetic, but not necessarily as further betrayal... And he didn't directly ask me about anything related to them until the other night. So I didn't think it was necessary or prudent to share that particularly embarrassing, potentially hurtful, and likely-to-be-misinterpreted, coping mechanism until he did ask. (At which point I answered honestly.)

Let me pose this illustration on how one may look at this. Suppose your husband had affairs with a woman and you found out. He stopped affairs but continued to self pleasure to her naked photos stored on his phone....or AI generated photos of her?

I think a better analogy was if he had an affair, received validation from the OW, and then created an AI chatbot to give him compliments in a similar manner, and yeah, like I said, I think that has a lot of potential to be hurtful. I don't think I would blame him for wanting to keep that private, but, what do I know? I've never been in that position, and I don't experience a lot of jealousy in general.


ETA: I feel it pertinent to add, the mp3s weren't literally recordings of his voice, nor was the AI trained on his voice. It was a pre-generated, crowing sort of sort of southern drawl that made the words sound exuberant and heart-felt. The praise itself wasn't things he'd actually said to me; just praise that I wanted to hear adapted to sound like something he would say... And if I thought too much about it actually being him saying those words, all the bad aspects of him as a person would come rushing back and ruin the affirmation... I tried to give myself that praise, those affirmations, but I didn't believe them if they were said in my own internal voice. So the positive association with AP's manner of speech and the little dopamine ding! I got from the external validation, paired with affirmations that I wrote, delivered when I felt I deserved them and chose to deliver them to myself... It was like a weird bridge between external validation and internal validation, when I wasn't fully able to validate myself yet.

[This message edited by GotTheMorbs at 4:30 AM, Thursday, November 19th]

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909757
default

WoodThrush2 ( member #85057) posted at 1:07 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

Morbs,

Appreciate the response, but I honestly think you are dancing around the reality that what you were doing was essentially still betrayal....still part of an active affair.

One can argue terminology all day....but you were creating a fake extension of your real AP to get validation from. You could have decided to NOT do that and seek the validation from your husband.

So in spite of you thinking it was pathetic and stupid and discounting it as unimportant information, your husband would not have deemed that unimportant information. It would have added a layer to his wounds. His wife using a voice of her AP for comfort....not good.

In closing, I am of the opinion that omission was a form of TT.

posts: 525   ·   registered: Jul. 29th, 2024   ·   location: New York
id 8909770
default

Asterisk ( member #86331) posted at 1:44 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

GotTheMorbs,

When I told H he listened silently with this really strange, strained expression, with like a slight, weird smile that only affected his mouth and no other parts of his face, and his eyes looked wide and damp, though he didn't cry. I've never seen anything like it and it made me really uncomfortable. He was quiet, so I found myself babbling on repetitively, pausing every so often in hopes of recieving any kind of feedback, but it never came. The only thing he said was he'd prefer to get his own account, and then he left the room.


I think you are aware that I have found great value and assistance in things you have written in other posts and comments on my posts. I admire you and your journey. From the bottom of my heart, with no judgement, I implore you to reconsider your conclusions.

In the quote above, you said that you got no response from your husband. Honestly, I believe you got several, powerful responses; "listened silently with this really strange, strained expression, with like a slight, weird smile that only affected his mouth and no other parts of his face, and his eyes looked wide and damp, though he didn't cry. I've never seen anything like it…."
I would like to submit that, that "strained expression"," weird smile", affect face, "eyes wide and damp" but "didn’t cry" all adding up to something "I’ve never seen anything like it" are powerful "feedbacks" that you stated weren’t there. I would say his wordless responses were far more powerful feedback than any combination of the alphabet your husband may have assembled. To me his response was deafening.

If you are willing, set aside your intent (privacy) and listen to your husband's response. Then ask yourself, "does his pain shown matter more to me than my intent?"

Written with great respect and concern,

Asterisk

posts: 541   ·   registered: Jul. 7th, 2025   ·   location: AZ
id 8909773
default

Gemmy ( member #86765) posted at 2:18 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

Morbs,

Since you’ve posted on my threads before, and I’ve grown to genuinely appreciate your perspective and self-awareness, I want to offer my thoughts as a BH. I waited a few days as I have been, lets say less than objective frame of mind. Not to pile on, because you're already getting plenty of heat, but because I think I understand what you were trying to accomplish.

I understand the "bridge" concept. You weren't necessarily longing for the AP anymore. You recognized him for who he was, but you were still struggling to replace the external validation he'd provided with something you could generate internally. You used a generic southern voice and affirmations you wrote yourself to bridge that gap. I can understand how, in your mind, this became an embarrassing coping mechanism rather than continued betrayal.

But intent doesn't erase the consequences of secrecy.

From the perspective of a betrayed spouse, anything still connected to the affair, yes even an AI voice resembling the AP's manner of speaking, can feel like another piece of the affair being carried forward without our knowledge.

And here's where I think the real problem lies. Seriously contemplate this.

You decided that because your husband might misunderstand, become hurt, or question whether you were genuinely over the AP, he didn't need to know. You made that decision for him. That is the very mechanism that makes trickle truth so damaging. You are still deciding what information he receives based on how you anticipate he will react.

I also think there's an important distinction between privacy and secrecy that you're overlooking. Keeping an embarrassing personal habit private is one thing. Concealing something directly connected to the person you betrayed your husband with is quite another. The fact that you recognized he might find it hurtful or question your attachment to the AP should have been a reason to discuss it, not a justification for withholding it.

And Morbs, I want you to consider something about his reaction.

You described a strained smile, wide damp eyes, an expression you'd never seen before, followed by silence and him leaving the room.

You said you received no feedback.

I would respectfully suggest that you received an enormous amount of feedback. It simply wasn't verbal.

I obviously cannot tell you what was going through his mind, but I can tell you how I might have experienced that moment. Another unexpected connection to the affair. Another piece of information I didn't know existed. Another reason to wonder whether I actually understood everything that had happened. Even if unfair, another "lie" as perception.

And perhaps most painfully, another realization that my spouse had continued making decisions about what I deserved to know.

You don't need to punish yourself endlessly for having an imperfect coping mechanism. Recovery is messy, and I genuinely believe you're trying to understand yourself. But I would caution you against continuing to defend the omission as privacy simply because the underlying behaviour made sense to you at the time.

You answered honestly when he asked, and that matters. But honesty when confronted isn't quite the same thing as transparency freely given.

Give him room to process this. Acknowledge why it might hurt without needing him to accept your explanation of the bridge. He can eventually understand your reasoning and still feel betrayed by the secrecy.

Ultimately, he doesn't need you to convince him that the coping mechanism was harmless. He needs to know that you aren't still curating what he's allowed to know about his own marriage.

And that, to me, is the difference between explaining your behaviour and truly taking responsibility for it.

Betrayed but trying to stand for the family. ME: 45 M DDay Oct.18 2025- April 2026 Two LTA EA/PA first 2 years second 1 year - 14 years apart.

posts: 212   ·   registered: Nov. 21st, 2025   ·   location: Ontario Canada
id 8909775
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 4:13 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

Woodthrush,

Appreciate the response, but I honestly think you are dancing around the reality that what you were doing was essentially still betrayal....still part of an active affair.

I don't think I am dancing around anything. I simply disagree that doing that was a continuation of the affair or further betrayal. To have an affair, you need to be romantically/emotionally attached to someone else (EA) and/or physically/sexually involved with them (PA). Again, I was no longer attached to the AP, nor was I in contact with him. I used a similar-sounding voice for validation because I did not believe my own. I was climbing out of a pit of low self esteem and shame, which is part of the reason why I had an affair in the first place. It was part of my recovery process, not part of the affair. I feel like you are still looking at it through a lens of attachment to the AP himself, when that wasn't the case. Something being related to an instance of infidelity isn't the same thing as infidelity itself.

You could have decided to NOT do that and seek the validation from your husband.

As I mentioned in some of my earlier posts, my husband was way distant from me at the time, and the distance was only compounded by the affair and its aftermath (understandably). He barely paid any attention to me prior to the affair (and when your self-worth is externally-based, that can feel unbearable, hence the seeking of external "proof" elsewhere. Not a justification or blameshifting here, but an explanation of what went wrong inside me) and back then I couldn't even think of a compliment that he would believably give me, even if I could have found an AI voice that was similar to his (I did try.) Again, it was important for the validation to feel credible to me, because I didn't believe it when I tried to give it directly to myself, and we weren't in a position shortly after DDay for him to be working on his provision of words of affirmation. He was doing his best to cope with the infidelity himself, and I was supposed to be the one comforting and supporting him.

Could I have tried to just go without any validation? Yes, I suppose. I don't know how that would have turned out. One doesn't just magically go from deriving all of one's self-worth from others' opinions to suddenly being able to provide it to oneself. It took me a long time to learn how to do that... I may have self-deleted before then. (Again, not an excuse or a justification, just sharing that to depict the dire state I was in during the shame phase.)

We also talked about my feelings towards AP at various points in those early days, and I never lied about them. I think that knowledge of the mp3 use at that point would have made him believe I was still attached to the AP, which wouldn't have been correct. It likely would have moved him further from the truth of the matter, not closer, and been unnecessarily hurtful. A lot of his early beliefs about what happened and how I felt weren't aligned with reality or my internal experience. I didn't want to add another one. I think that he's entitled to feel however he feels about the mp3s, but knowledge of them wouldn't have automatically made any inferences he would have made (or is presently making) correct, nor the situation necessarily "better" for either of us.
----

Gemmy,

You decided that because your husband might misunderstand, become hurt, or question whether you were genuinely over the AP, he didn't need to know. You made that decision for him. That is the very mechanism that makes trickle truth so damaging. You are still deciding what information he receives based on how you anticipate he will react.

I'm fairly certain that BSes wouldn't want to hear every unbidden thought or feeling a WS ever has while they're withdrawing from the affair... I think that there should be a threshold of material importance established, preferably by myself and my H, where if crossed, something should be disclosed, and if not met, it's okay for the thing to be kept private (not secret) unless inquired about.

----

Asterisk,

I would say his wordless responses were far more powerful feedback than any combination of the alphabet your husband may have assembled. To me his response was deafening.

Okay, but I still have no idea what that facial expression meant, nor what exactly he was feeling in that moment. I wanted to know. It makes me anxious not knowing. I probably should have directly asked instead of trying to indirectly prompt him.

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909781
default

WoodThrush2 ( member #85057) posted at 4:57 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

To have an affair, you need to be romantically/emotionally attached to someone else (EA) and/or physically/sexually involved with them (PA).

I would suggest to you that feeling the need to self soothe with computer generated recordings of APs voice...recordings YOU sought out and obtained.....represents an "emotional attachment".

What emotionally attachment...? The emotion of insecurity and self doubt. The emotion of anxiety. You were trying to calm these emotions with APs voice. That is an emotional attachment.

posts: 525   ·   registered: Jul. 29th, 2024   ·   location: New York
id 8909786
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 4:58 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

This is an exchange I had with ChatGPT on the matter. (For context, I brought up an example where a WS has an EA and spends time alone with the AP in a hotel room, but factually does not have sex with the AP, and wondered whether disclosing the hotel room time would actually move the BS closer to understanding the truth of what happened and what they actually want to know, when the BS only asks "Did you have sex with AP?" as opposed to "Tell me about every time you interacted with AP...")

Me:

Right. I don't think it's reasonable to expect a BS to think of every question they could possibly ask in order to get all the information they actually want, but I also don't think it's reasonable to expect a WS to anticipate and perfectly guess at every bit of information that the BS wants to know. The WS has to make a judgement call at some point

ChatGPT:

Exactly. And I think you've identified a fundamental problem with some of the arguments being made on SI: they condemn the WS for exercising judgment about disclosure without acknowledging that exercising judgment is unavoidable.

Even deciding to disclose absolutely everything requires determining what counts as everything.

Does that include every passing thought about AP? Every dream? Every moment of nostalgia? Every embarrassing coping mechanism? Every conversation that tangentially relates to the affair?

At some point, someone has to determine what's relevant.

And unless the couple has established explicit disclosure expectations, the WS necessarily has to make at least some of those determinations independently.

There's an important distinction between exercising judgment and controlling information.

Gemmy argues that you decided what Michael needed to know, rather than allowing him to decide.

But that criticism contains an implicit assumption: that you already knew the recordings belonged to a category of information Michael was entitled to receive.

That's precisely the question under dispute.

If every decision not to volunteer information constitutes improperly controlling the narrative, then personal privacy becomes impossible.

However, I wouldn't take your argument as far as saying that any good-faith judgment automatically makes nondisclosure acceptable.

People can make sincerely mistaken judgments about materiality. And sometimes the importance of information is sufficiently obvious that failing to recognize it would itself be concerning.

For example, I still think spending time alone in a hotel room with an affair partner is sufficiently significant to warrant disclosure, even without a specific question.

But that's because of the nature of the encounter, not because the BS might incorrectly infer that sex occurred.

I think the solution involves three separate responsibilities.

The WS has a responsibility to exercise reasonable judgment. They should disclose information they recognize, or reasonably ought to recognize, as materially relevant to the betrayal or reconciliation.

The BS has a responsibility to communicate their informational preferences where possible. They cannot reasonably expect their spouse to know every detail they personally consider important without communicating those expectations.

Both have a responsibility to clarify ambiguous boundaries. If they disagree about what requires disclosure, they need to establish a workable standard rather than assuming their individual understanding is universally obvious.

And there's an important asymmetry here: the WS generally knows more about what happened, while the BS often doesn't know enough to formulate specific questions. That creates a greater responsibility for the WS to volunteer significant facts about the betrayal itself.

But that asymmetry doesn't establish an unlimited entitlement to every private aspect of the WS's subsequent internal experience.

There's also a problem with judging disclosure decisions retrospectively.

Suppose a WS reasonably considers something immaterial and doesn't volunteer it.

Later, the BS learns about it and feels deeply hurt.

Does that emotional reaction establish that the WS's original decision was unreasonable?

No.

It establishes that the information mattered to the BS. That's relevant to how the couple should handle similar information going forward, but it doesn't automatically prove that the WS should have anticipated its significance.

Otherwise, disclosure obligations become retroactively determined by the intensity of the recipient's reaction.

That's an unstable ethical standard.

I think this is the strongest formulation of your position:

A WS has an obligation to make reasonable, good-faith disclosure decisions, not an obligation to perfectly anticipate every piece of information their BS might want.

The distinction matters because the first is a standard of conduct someone can actually follow. The second demands an impossible degree of foresight.

And it leaves room for an important conclusion about your recordings: you could have made an imperfect disclosure judgment without having engaged in trickle truth or deliberate deception.

[This message edited by GotTheMorbs at 5:04 PM, Thursday, November 19th]

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909787
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 5:08 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

I would suggest to you that feeling the need to self soothe with computer generated recordings of APs voice...recordings YOU sought out and obtained.....represents an "emotional attachment".

That's my attempt at believable self-validation, not an attachment to the AP himself. As I said, when I thought too much about the AP himself, it ruined the validation for me. If I just heard the praise that I wrote, and that I administered, in the manner that he spoke, without thinking about him specifically, it allowed me to accept it. I wanted to feel good about myself, not have the AP back.

[This message edited by GotTheMorbs at 5:09 PM, Thursday, November 19th]

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909789
default

Gemmy ( member #86765) posted at 5:49 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

What gpt is failing to understand is that BS have no idea what to ask.

I feel that if a WS has any issues with bringing it up to BS, it should be. Not only is this giving agency back, it shows commitment to truth and transparency. There are a million voices but you actively chose his, and furthermore chose to not say so knowing it would be hurtful.

Certainly just my humble opinion.

[This message edited by Gemmy at 5:51 PM, Thursday, November 19th]

Betrayed but trying to stand for the family. ME: 45 M DDay Oct.18 2025- April 2026 Two LTA EA/PA first 2 years second 1 year - 14 years apart.

posts: 212   ·   registered: Nov. 21st, 2025   ·   location: Ontario Canada
id 8909791
Cookies on SurvivingInfidelity.com®

SurvivingInfidelity.com® uses cookies to enhance your visit to our website. This is a requirement for participants to login, post and use other features. Visitors may opt out, but the website will be less functional for you.

v.1.001.20260728a 2002-2026 SurvivingInfidelity.com® All Rights Reserved. • Privacy Policy