Cookies are required for login or registration. Please read and agree to our cookie policy to continue.

Newest Member: MissTee00

Wayward Side :
When Is Omission TT?

default

Unconventional ( member #87720) posted at 6:02 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

People!

I haven't been keeping up with this thread and just saw where it stands.

If I was Morbs's H, I would've been crushed that my W felt the need to program compliments in a voice like her AP's--but not because I'd have seen an AI-driven emulation of the AP as a kind of continuation of the A or my delayed discovery of the old habit as a TT situation.

The melancholy I'd have felt would've been from shame and horror over having given my W compliments so deficiently that my beloved felt compelled to obtain them through AI--and even then, seemingly thought that my voice either wouldn't seem authentic in praise of her or didn't choose to hear praise in my voice.

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 189   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909792
default

LittleMonk ( member #86661) posted at 6:06 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

I would've been crushed that my W felt the need to program compliments in a voice like her AP's

I think most of us would.

- LM BH Reconciled

Dday: 12/2024

"The hardest cage to sit in is the one where you hold the key, knowing exactly what freedom looks like on the outside."

posts: 115   ·   registered: Oct. 10th, 2025   ·   location: North Carolina
id 8909793
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 6:10 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

What gpt is failing to understand is that BS have no idea what to ask.

ChatGPT and I have both acknowledged that a BS cannot be reasonably expected to know what to ask to get the exact degree of information they desire.

The counterpart to that is that a WS can be willing to give the BS all the information they desire... But they have no way of knowing what exact information a BS wants or doesn't want without the BS communicating it. There has to be a degrees of judgement exercised, to the best of the WS's ability.

Consider that there are BSes that appear on JFO who say they want every last bit of information they can acquire, even the most minute, painful details (like positions, orgasms, how many times, etc.) and other BSes who only want the most basic of information (like "sex was had." Period.)

My understanding of the situation was that my H wanted to know how I felt about AP himself, and I truthfully disclosed that information. I believed that disclosure of the mp3 use would have be misleading and contrary to his desire for the truth. I believed that he didn't want to know every unbidden thought I had about the AP or the A during my withdrawal period, because such things are painful, and I compared the mp3 use to such thoughts. I believed he wouldn't have understood why I was doing it, nor believed me if I provided context.

I could have been wrong about what he did and didn't want to know. But I also don't have a reliable way of predicting that in every instance. I can comply with and provide, to the best of my ability, with what he explicitly says he wants to know. But even then I have to judge whether a particular thing falls within the explicit guidelines. And one cannot ask if someone wants a specific disclosure without first making the disclosure.

So I think the judgement of my decision here is a bit unfair.

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909794
default

KitchenDepth5551 ( member #83934) posted at 6:13 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

Full disclosure: I did not read all the posts here. I read the main one and skimmed a few.

If my WH had revealed this, it would have me on the bathroom floor in a sobbing pile of mess. It wouldn't even have been a thought in my mind to ask if he'd done anything like it. Yet, I would want to know. I would really, really want to know.

My WH's affair was rather short and not as dramatically physical as many here. He did give me a timeline and take a poly. There wasn't much TT. But probably the major factor is re-establishing trust is that he told me incredibly painful things he thought and said to AP. They were things I';d have no way of ever knowing otherwise. I appreciated that. He posted about it here or on another forum. I read tons of comments telling him it was wrong and cruel to tell me. I fully disagree.

Recently I re-watched a movie I saw shortly after the affair. It's been 10 years or so. It's called The Other Man. It's obviously about infidelity. They're in a long-term marriage. The wife dies, and the husband finds out she had been having an affair. The thing that struck me about the movie is that at the end, the husband says, "She never really knew me." Sure, he didn't know her; she hid things. But also, she didn't know him. He didn't hide anything.

It's true. I don't hide anything from my husband. How could he not know how I would feel about an affair and what would hurt me or not hurt me and how much it would affect me? That's the person who should know me the best. He didn't.

As your BS, I think that's how I would feel about the whole situation.

posts: 354   ·   registered: Sep. 27th, 2023
id 8909795
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 6:18 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

The melancholy I'd have felt would've been from shame and horror over having given my W compliments so deficiently that my beloved felt compelled to obtain them through AI--and even then, seemingly thought that my voice either wouldn't seem authentic in praise of her or didn't choose to hear praise in my voice.

It's not my fault that my husband wasn't prone to giving me compliments, such that I couldn't imagine any he would plausibly say.

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909796
default

LittleMonk ( member #86661) posted at 6:20 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

Consider that there are BSes that appear on JFO who say they want every last bit of information they can acquire, even the most minute, painful details (like positions, orgasms, how many times, etc.) and other BSes who only want the most basic of information (like "sex was had." Period.)

The only way to know, is for the betrayed to communicate exactly what they do want to know. In my case it was every detail. I had to know what I was forgiving before I could do so. So that is what I asked for.

"She never really knew me."

Yes, there was heavy masking involved with most of our marriage. I was vulnerable and transparent. She assumed I was masking also.

- LM BH Reconciled

Dday: 12/2024

"The hardest cage to sit in is the one where you hold the key, knowing exactly what freedom looks like on the outside."

posts: 115   ·   registered: Oct. 10th, 2025   ·   location: North Carolina
id 8909797
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 6:30 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

But probably the major factor is re-establishing trust is that he told me incredibly painful things he thought and said to AP. They were things I';d have no way of ever knowing otherwise. I appreciated that. He posted about it here or on another forum. I read tons of comments telling him it was wrong and cruel to tell me. I fully disagree.

The mp3s weren't things I said to AP, or things AP said to me. They were word I wrote, and things I wanted to say to myself. AP's speech mannerisms were just the delivery mechanism because the lingering association with his voice and receiving validation allowed me to accept my own praise, with the ultimate goal of not needing to use the mp3s. The mp3s weren't part of the affair itself. I disclosed everything I could think of with regard to the actual affair itself. I disclosed my actual feelings about AP, as well as my progress with the ability to self-validate, to my H as recovery progressed.

I know my husband very well. I'm still not an infallible mind-reader, and correctly-done infidelity recovery (rather than rug-sweeping and waiting out my time in the doghouse) was new territory for both of us.

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909798
default

KitchenDepth5551 ( member #83934) posted at 6:33 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

"She never really knew me."

Yes, there was heavy masking involved with most of our marriage. I was vulnerable and transparent. She assumed I was masking also.

Yes. Of course I want to know everything. Every last detail. If you know me, how could you not know that? Of course I said that; but if you know me, do I really need to tell you that? I don't want any secrets in my marriage.

GotTheMorbs, Do you know what your BH wants to know or not know?

I think the husband in the movie was partly saying he would have wanted to talk to her about all of it during her terminal illness before she died. She truly didn't understand him.

Edit: What I'm trying to express, probably not eloquently as others here could, is that it is equally or more painful to realize that you were not fully known or seen by your partner than it is to realize that you didn't know them.

[This message edited by KitchenDepth5551 at 6:51 PM, Thursday, November 19th]

posts: 354   ·   registered: Sep. 27th, 2023
id 8909799
default

KitchenDepth5551 ( member #83934) posted at 6:56 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

Ok. I understand that you didn't say words to your AP..

GotTheMorbs, my thoughts or words are not getting through to your understanding of my points. It's probably my fault.

I would want to know. I would want to know every single teeny, tiny thought in my WH's head at every point in the process. Of course you would know that if you knew me. Of course I said that to my WH.

I hope I don't have typos here. I'm trying to use my contacts.

posts: 354   ·   registered: Sep. 27th, 2023
id 8909800
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 6:58 PM on Thursday, November 19th, 2026

I can ask him what he wants to know, and he can provide me guidelines. That still doesn't eliminate the requirement for me to judge what falls into those guidelines and what doesn't.

At the time of the mp3s, my guidelines for what he wanted to know were: everything that happened during the affair as well as every other instance of infidelity he could think of (disclosed to the best of my ability), why I did what I did (disclosed as I figured it out), whether I was still in contact with AP (no) and if he attempted to re-open communication (disclosed each time), how I felt about AP (truthfully disclosed as it changed), how I felt about H (continually,. constantly, and thoroughly disclosed from pre-affair, during the affair, and post-affair), and what I was working on in my recovery process (also disclosed: making self-worth and -validation come from internal sources rather than external sources, though the mp3s were omitted.)

It's not like he said "I want to know every thought you have or action you take even remotely associated with the AP, and here's a definitions section and an exhaustive list of everything that qualifies..." and then I was like "well he definitely wants to know about the mp3s and I just won't tell him."

ETA: I still don't even know if he would have wanted to know about the mp3s sooner or not.

[This message edited by GotTheMorbs at 7:09 PM, Thursday, November 19th]

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909801
default

Unconventional ( member #87720) posted at 1:50 AM on Friday, November 20th, 2026

It's not my fault that my husband wasn't prone to giving me compliments, such that I couldn't imagine any he would plausibly say.

I didn’t mean you were guilty of anything in having set up and used the recordings.

But, without meaning to put too fine of a point on the observation: who did choose your husband, if not you?

I will offer a small additional note of feedback: I, who am autistic, tend to freeze up under extreme pressure and say what absolutely is socially the worst possible thing one could say in moments of great stress--intending none of the fallout I create for myself. (If you’ve never seen the "literal doctor" clips from the old TV series "Arrested Development," they're totally worth a watch for a sympathetic wry laugh!)

Anyhow, I wish—when your H asked you why you had that account—that you had been able to tell him a little white lie. I think you know deep down that listening to an AI voice pay you compliments you wtote was NOT a continuation of an affair (no matter what anyone else says here). Therefore, you didn’t necessarily owe your H the full truth. But we autists tend to get locked into "always tell the truth" mode. It can be endearing. Tell enough people who slaved over their pies in a baking contest that their pie was terrible and you’re sure to stumble across someone who appreciates the candor because it makes the next words of praise from you ring all the more authentic and valid! But, in this case, I really do think the caring thing to have said to a spouse was almost anything other than the truth. So long as you could clean up the account before your H got to log into it.

I do hope that the abundance with which your H compliments you was only in a transient slump at the time. I "hear" only what you post, so my impressions of your H emerges from barely a sliver of a visual window, but I worry (from the little I hear of him) that he may habitually be a little overcritical of you and a little too reticent to compliment you. I could see that feeling quite ordinary—maybe even comfortingly familiar—to someone who had your stepdad as a parent. Just be aware that those of us with softer and more adoring parents might find such handling repellent—or at least chide-worthy.

I think the atmosphere at this website is broadly awfully caustic. Too many people are too quick to dredge up old platitudes as weapons of war or to read into a poster’s words surreptitiously evil motives and hack at a person. Too many people here are too quick to condemn others for small mistakes and too quick to acquit themselves of the flaws they so readily spot in others. That doesn’t mean we don’t all have room for a little improvement!

There legitimately are a few good souls here. HikingOut and you, Morbs, particularly come to mind, although I don’t intend that list as exhaustive. I’m far from concordant with you on a whole host of issues and even meta-ethics, but I find no bad motive in either of you.

[This message edited by Unconventional at 11:45 AM, Friday, November 20th]

Sincerely, Unconventional

posts: 189   ·   registered: Aug. 26th, 2026   ·   location: Mid-Atlantic, USA
id 8909814
default

WoodThrush2 ( member #85057) posted at 2:41 AM on Friday, November 20th, 2026

KitchenDepth ...I am with you.

I needed, and essentially demanded ..to know every little thing. I even asked about intentions, energy, etc. I wanted to grieve it all.

posts: 525   ·   registered: Jul. 29th, 2024   ·   location: New York
id 8909818
default

KitchenDepth5551 ( member #83934) posted at 4:44 PM on Friday, November 20th, 2026

I needed, and essentially demanded ..to know every little thing

WoodThrush2, As BS's I think we can clearly state or beg or demand all we want, but it's all up to the WS if they wish to change and become honest and active participants. It's clear some do and some do not. In retrospect, I can see the evidence that my WH was willingly disengaging before d-day. He said he knew he had to make a change. I think that's similar to hikingout.


EDIT: I guess I'm saying I don't think there's anything that I did or said that changed the situation. It was always going to be what it was going to be. I do think it all comes out in the end as long as you don't rug sweep. That makes it hard to give advice here.

[This message edited by KitchenDepth5551 at 4:58 PM, Friday, November 20th]

posts: 354   ·   registered: Sep. 27th, 2023
id 8909906
default

sisoon ( Moderator #31240) posted at 4:45 PM on Friday, November 20th, 2026

The counterpart to that is that a WS can be willing to give the BS all the information they desire... But they have no way of knowing what exact information a BS wants or doesn't want without the BS communicating it. There has to be a degrees of judgement exercised, to the best of the WS's ability.

My bet is that d-day wipes the slate clean with regard to BS and WS being able to understand each other's non-verbal communication.

The best approach, IMO, is to respond to the literal words one hears and to say what one means and mean what one says. That is, reduce the filtering to an absolute minimum, and keep reducing it as the ability to read non-verbals builds. Part of that is, in answering questions, just the facts, with as little filtering as possible. If it's TMI, it's up to the listener to say so.

It's clear you misread your H. He probably misreads you, too, but he's not posting in this thread. Stop trying to read his mind. Stop trying to 'protect' him. He's a big boy.

My reco is to try out answering your H's literal questions and following each answer up with something like, 'Is that answer what you're looking for?'

Kudos for giving the answer that we've been discussing. You could have minimized, but you didn't. You brought a conflict to the surface, where it can be resolved. That's a win IMO.

You're walking on eggshells. How is that good for you, for your H, or for your daughter?

fBH (me) - on d-day: 66, Married 43, together 45, same sex ap
d-day - 12/22/2010 Recover'd and R'ed
You don't have to like your boundaries. You just have to set and enforce them.

posts: 32358   ·   registered: Feb. 18th, 2011   ·   location: Illinois
id 8909907
default

 GotTheMorbs (original poster member #86894) posted at 9:40 PM on Friday, November 20th, 2026

Unconventional,

But, without meaning to put too fine of a point on the observation: who did choose your husband, if not you?

When I chose him, he gave me validation in other, nonverbal ways... In the beginning when you're getting to know someone, there's lots to talk about, and I thought that kind of interest and connection would continue throughout our lives together. He'd also been in a 20 year long, very toxic, sexless marriage, and he made me feel like water to a man who'd been lost in the desert for days. I chalked the lack of words of affirmation up to the emotional stuntedness from his previous relationship and his FOO trauma, and figured he'd come around eventually ("I can fix him!" Well, I got him to say "I love you," if only occasionally.)

Anyhow, I wish—when your H asked you why you had that account—that you had been able to tell him a little white lie.

I don't lie anymore. Part of the post-infidelity Rules. It's better and safer that way.

I worry (from the little I hear of him) that he may habitually be a little overcritical of you and a little too reticent to compliment you.

The other night as I was preparing for him to arrive home, I made him some tea and turned the lights on for him, as he likes for us to do, I wondered if he even noticed and appreciated when I did that, or if he only noticed (and consequently complained) when I didn't. I texted him the question, and he candidly replied that it was mostly the latter... I hope maybe that will cause him to look for things to be positive about. And maybe the knowledge of the mp3s will cause him to understand that I crave words of affirmation-- though not as much as I used to, as I believe them when they come from within now.

I think the BSes are just replying from a very specific perspective, and that's alright. I did invite them by requesting the stop sign to be removed.

[This message edited by GotTheMorbs at 9:41 PM, Friday, November 20th]

Far too often in our hasty, mad quest to *Be Loved,* we lose sight of the fact that we are inherently, uniquely, and divinely *Loveable.*

----

I'm not arguing... I'm calibrating

posts: 630   ·   registered: Jan. 5th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909953
Cookies on SurvivingInfidelity.com®

SurvivingInfidelity.com® uses cookies to enhance your visit to our website. This is a requirement for participants to login, post and use other features. Visitors may opt out, but the website will be less functional for you.

v.1.001.20260728a 2002-2026 SurvivingInfidelity.com® All Rights Reserved. • Privacy Policy